What to Mix With Screwball Whiskey?

Did you see someone mixing peanut butter with whiskey? Are you skeptical about how it would taste? Do you want to know what you can mix with screwball whiskey to make it taste wonderful?

Read further!

According to Statista, almost eleven percent of Americans drink whiskey once a week. Most of them try out new combinations. One such combination gave out Screwball Whiskey. Time to try this unique combination. Shall we explore it now?

What To Mix With Screwball Whiskey?

Peanut butter and whiskey are two things that most of us can’t say no to. What if they come together? Screwball whiskey is a combination of peanut butter, whiskey- corn, and barley with a sweetener which is cane sugar. It is seventy percent proofed and has thirty-five percentage of alcohol by volume in it. It gives out a sweetish taste with the feeling of peanut butter in taste. Let us see what else can be added to it to enhance our taste buds.

Holiday Peanut Butter Whiskey Balls

These yummy whiskey balls are the output we get when we mix peanut butter whiskey, peanut butter, sugar, honey, cocoa which is unsweetened, kosher salt, peanut, and finally vanilla wafers.

Now add peanuts which are chopped finely into vanilla wafer crumbs in a bowl. It is time to stir these with all the other ingredients leaving out sugar and cocoa powder. Make balls out of the mixture of the ingredients and roll them on sugar and cocoa powder. These balls are a must-try when you are bored of having the whiskey routinely.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Drink Recipe

Did you ever know adding raspberry to your whiskey will result in a delicious cocktail? Chambord and peanut butter whiskey mix will give out the best cocktail mix. Just add some ice and garnish your drink with raspberries. It is good to go now. Enjoy your drink.

See also  How Much Whiskey Does It Take to Get Drunk?

Screwball Whiskey Milkshake Recipe

Are you a big fan of coffee? Want to explore its taste by adding it into whiskey? Then make this one. Take some scoops of coffee ice cream, add some peanut butter whiskey and blend them. The milkshake is ready. Using whipped cream, chocolate syrup, milk for garnishing is your choice. Want to see if it goes well with any other flavor? Then change the ice cream flavor you have used.

Do let us know what other flavors made it tastier.

Drinks Recipe With Screwball Whiskey

Screwed Up Dalgona

Dalgona coffee is a very popular drink. Why not mix two popular drinks and see what it gives out. This drink just takes a few ingredients; add instant coffee powder, sugar, water, vanilla vodka, almond milk, and some whiskey. Now stir some whiskey, vodka, and milk and add whipped cream made out of coffee powder, sugar, and water.

Screwball Whiskey Peanut Butter Cup Shots

These shots are an output of peanut butter whiskey, milk, and coffee liquor. So take a shaker, add whiskey, milk, and coffee liquor, add some ice cubes and shake it. Now add the liquid into your desired glass and serve it. Before doing this, if you want to make it look more appealing, melt some peanut butter cups and take some golden sprinkles. Take the glass, dip it in melted chocolate, and immediately dip it in sprinkles. Take extra peanut butter cups, dip them in melted chocolate and directly keep it on the glass and leave it to dry, now pour the drink, and enjoy.

See also  Difference Between Cognac and Whisky?

Apple Cider Peanut Butter Whiskey Cocktail

This must be taken drink when the temperature is low because this is a warm drink. Are you having a party tonight? Want to impress the guests with your presentation? Then take the glass to apply some peanut butter on the rim, and dip it in sugar made of cinnamon. Now time for the drink; pour some peanut butter whiskey into the glass on the top of it add some warm apple cider vinegar. Put some apple slices into the drink and garnish it with a cinnamon stick. It is ready to be served now.

Peanut Butter Whiskey Old Fashioned

Making a peanut butter whiskey old-fashioned is very easy. For this, you will need whiskey, bitters, orange, and cherries. Pour the whiskey into the glass, cut an orange into slices, and add it.

Now add ice cubes and two cherries and some bitters, and mix them to serve the desired drink.

Hot Peanut Butter Toddy

Are you in search of something hot, light, and also hydrating? Then pick this one. Hot Peanut Butter Toddy, as the name, has hot water as the main ingredient. It also has lemon, honey, peanut butter whiskey as other ingredients in it. So people drink this mix of all these ingredients and sip it slowly. This is also a drink that is best to be taken when you have symptoms of cold and cough.

Peanut Butter Fizz

This is something new. This is a recipe where you mix an egg with whiskey. Take only whites of two eggs, some milk, bitters of chocolate, coffee liquor, and screwball whiskey. Now take a shaker mix all the above. Add ice into the shaker, shake it, remove the ice, and shake again to get fluffy egg whites. Now pour into glasses and add soda water on the top of it. If you want to give a classy look, add some cocoa powder on top of the drink.

See also  Silver Tray for Whiskey Decanter

Cocktail Recipe With Screwball Whiskey

Frequently Asked Questions:

Does Screwball Whiskey Have Peanut Butter in It?

As popularly as peanut butter whiskey, screwball whiskey is made out of whiskey with peanut butter. It is made with a mixture of original peanuts and sweet and gives us a nutty feeling in our mouth when we drink it. Sometimes it feels like we are eating peanut butter when we consume it.

What Do You Mean by Bitters?

Bitters are nothing but similar to salt. When we add salt to the food, it will balance the taste and enhance the flavor. Similarly, when we add bitters, they balance the drink’s flavors and bring out the best. Bitters are majorly added in many cocktails to make them taste the best.


So, people, this was about the double gold medal winner of best-flavored whiskey. Go through our article and try any of our mentioned recipes, and feel free to comment and let us know anything on screwball whiskey, which is popularly known as the black sheep of the whiskeys. Happy drinking!